When I was in elementary school, through the Scholastic book orders or book fairs, my dad bought me the box set of The Chronicles of Narnia. Back then I’d no clue about the publication order. I was only familiar with the chronological order that was displayed in the box set, with the The Magician’s Nephew being the first title. Needless to say, my foray into Narnia involved me reading that first book.
It. Bored. Me. I had no idea what was going on. I think I skipped it and then tried The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, and that kept me a bit more interested, but not by much. I only know for sure that I’d never got beyond the first two books in my elementary, middle, and high school years. Even in my uni years, I just couldn’t really get into it, despite watching the film adaptation of The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe (of which I enjoyed!).
I finally read about how one should read the books in the publication order as opposed to chronological order, and that made me decide to tackle the series that way. It took a couple of months, but I’ve read the entire set, and I must say that the publication order made a lot more sense and it kept me interested. Here are my spoiler-free thoughts on the series.
– REEPICHEEP. He’s the best character ever. That is all.
– Edmund also won me over. Going from a selfish little prick to a fine King is certainly a huge change for him.
– Puddlegum is about the only thing that made me enjoy The Silver Chair. His pessimism cracked me up.
– The entirety of The Horse and His Boy kept me fully interested. The plot was just amazing, with a good pacing for once. This is my favourite out of the series.
– My next favourite is The Voyage of the Dawn Treader. I love how it’s based off of The Odyssey, but I really love how it sets a major potential for Caspian/Edmund as a pairing, haha!
– Much like Tolkien did with his books, I love how Lewis created the world of Narnia. Everything about it fascinated me, and I just kept wanting to know more about the world. And I think that’s why I really liked The Horse and His Boy, because I got to see more than just Narnia — I saw how the world was like in Calormen and Archenland.
– I know these books are for children, but the pacing drove me nuts, especially in Prince Caspian.
– I still have no love for The Magician’s Nephew. I mean, this time, I understood what I read, but I think the effects of my earlier attempt with that book remains lingering, so it’s affecting my bias.
– I don’t know how I feel about the ending. I do feel like I’ve been cheated, but at the same time the ending fits the series very much.
– As an Atheist, I didn’t care for the Christian themes, but I still respected them as being plot points.
– JILL. In The Silver Chair. I absolutely could not stand her. Thank goodness she improves in the last book.
– In fact, I enjoyed The Silver Chair the least. I think it’s because there weren’t any Pevensie siblings, and Eustace just couldn’t replace them.
That was a satisfying read. It took me what — over two decades? — to read the series, but I’m glad I did. The world of Narnia definitely fascinated me to where I could overlook all the religious undertones. I’m not sure if I’d ever re-read the whole series, but I know I’ll re-read the ones I really liked, like The Voyage of the Dawn Treader.